Eastern Mineral and Environmental Resources Science Center
Environmental Geochemistry to Evaluate Risks Associated with Past and Future Mining in the Lake Superior Region
Activities and tasks of this project:
Task 1, Lake Superior Environmental Databases and Mineral-Environmental Assessment:
This task will take the concepts developed by the sunsetting mineral-environmental
assessment methodology project and apply them in a regional, deposit type specific context
to provide a scientifically based framework for decision-making regarding future mining to
benefit all stakeholders including land managers, the mining industry, regulatory agencies,
non-government organizations, and citizens. Data layers will include a variety of geologic, geochemical, hydrologic, climatic, ecological, demographic information to identify potential risks to the surrounding environment
associated with future mining. The Geographic Information Systems activities will be coordinated with the other Midcontinent Rift projects to share data layers and to avoid duplication. The geologic data
layers used will be derived from existing data sets or data sets being developed by
concurrent Midcontinent Rift projects. This project will focus on the construction of
environmental data layers such as those related to climate, hydrology, soil and sediment
geochemistry, and ecosystems. These environmental data layers will also be supplemented
by research being conducted in Tasks 2 and 3. The culminating assessment will be
designed to better inform the discussion surrounding future mining in the region.
Task 2, Baseline Characterization:
Task 2 will design and execute a field sampling program to fill crucial data gaps identified in
Task 1 (i.e., water chemistry, sediment chemistry, soil chemistry, etc.). An emphasis will be
placed on developing a modern perspective on the Lake Superior region in terms of recent
conceptual changes to regulatory guidelines by analyzing adequate sets of parameters to
enable complete characterization. For example, in 2007 the Environmental Protection Agency adopted a new method for
assessing the surface-water toxicity of copper called the "Biotic Ligand Model" that takes a
more sophisticated approach that relies on a larger set of water quality parameters than
previous regulatory guidelines, such as dissolved organic carbon concentrations in addition
to standard inorganic water quality parameters. Likewise, the model for assessing metal
toxicity in sediments now uses an approach known as the equilibrium-partitioning sediment
benchmark, which relies on a more extensive set of analytes including the concentrations of
acid-volatile sulfide, simultaneously extractable metals, and organic carbon.
Specific sampling areas will be coordinated with the Midwest Area Mining Initiative, for access to water resources data sets that otherwise would have been difficult to easily use, and worldclass
stream gaging data for the watersheds being investigated. Watersheds being targeted
include those associated with Duluth-type PGM deposits, banded iron formations, and
sediment-hosted copper deposits. The sulfate budget of these watersheds will be of
particular interest because of the ongoing interest in the Minnesota wild rice water-quality
standard for sulfate. The stable isotope signatures of dissolved sulfate will be compared
with known values for mineralized rocks to fingerprint contributions from various sources.
Geographic emphasis for the Duluth-style platinum group metal deposits will likely be the entire strike length
of the complex, for the iron ores it will likely be the Mesabi and Gogebic ranges, and for the
sediment-hosted copper deposits it will be the Porcupine Mountains area between the
inactive White Pine Mine to the east and the Copperwood advanced exploration project to
the west. Results from this task will contribute to the environmental GIS data base in Task
1.
Task 3, Geoenvironmental Models:
Task 3 will focus on defining and refining our understanding of the environmental
characteristics of Duluth-style PGM deposits, sediment-hosted copper deposits, and
banded iron formation deposits through literature review and new data collection.
Characteristics will include both pre-mining baseline conditions and the signatures
associated with mine waste and drainage.
The goal is to identify specific risks associated with each deposit type to enable these risks
to be ranked and addressed. An underlying theme will be to understand how the unique
combination of geologic characteristics of the mineral deposits and the local hydrologic,
geochemical, and climatic conditions conspire to determine the source, transport, and fate of
elements of environmental interest from mining. Deposit specific details will include
investigating mineralogic hosts of trace elements, acid-base accounting characteristics, and
leaching properties of unmined rock, waste rock, and mine wastes. A
major emphasis will be to understand controls of sulfate fluxes from unmined areas and
mined areas to provide a scientific context for understanding sulfate loads in surrounding
watersheds. These insights will be used to develop geoenvironmental models for these
deposit types customized to the Lake Superior region.